A Suitable Lie, by Michael J. Malone, is a psychological thriller exploring the complex issue of domestic abuse. In this tale it is the husband who is being abused. His reasons for staying within the marriage are compellingly presented.
The protagonist is Andy Boyd, a widowed father who enjoys a close and friendly relationship with his mother and brother. His father died when he was young. His first wife died giving birth to their son, Pat, who is now four years old. Andy is content with the quiet life the two of them lead. He has just benefited from a promotion at work where he manages a branch of a local bank. His mother considers him too young to settle for nothing more than work and parenting.
Andy’s brother, Jim, insists that they go to their rugby club for a night out. There Andy meets Anna, a beautiful and petite young woman who is new to the area. Andy and Jim are tall and well built rugby players. The contrast in stature is significant in their subsequent behaviour.
A whirlwind romance ensues. Despite his mother’s reservations, Andy and Anna marry. The bride-to-be had not been pleased when her future husband went away on a drunken stag weekend, but her paranoia fully manifests itself on their wedding night. Although shocked at his new young wife’s behaviour, Andy accepts her explanation and they settle into married life.
Anna’s volatile behaviour is described in detail, as is their early sexual activity. She is, at times, demanding, vicious and manipulative, playing to each of Andy’s weaknesses. His pride forbids him from letting anyone know what is going on.
In an attempt to mollify Anna, Andy distances himself from his mother and brother. His work begins to suffer, not helped by a series of irregularities in the bank’s accounts.
The short chapters help to maintain the tension. The reasons Andy puts up with so much are well explained. What was less clear is why he did not confide in his family, to whom he had been close, when the situation became so obviously dire. Perhaps my lack of empathy in this respect is because I am not a macho, Scottish male.
The story builds to a crisis point and the tension is then ratcheted up even more. The denouement is loaded with foreboding.
The author does a fine job of taking the reader inside Andy’s predicament. The twists at the end are skillfully presented.
I do have these few reservations around the plot. I do not enjoy reading details of sex and have little patience with machismo. I did not understand why Andy did not at least visit a doctor to have each set of injuries recorded. I cannot fault the writing style which was taut and potent throughout.
Abuse of either partner in a supposedly loving relationship is unacceptable yet is too often ignored. It can be tricky to prove exactly what goes on in the privacy of a home. Fiction is an effective way to get people empathising with such complexities. This book is also a gripping read.
My copy of this book was provided gratis by the publisher.
This review is a stop on the Suitable Lie Blog Tour. Do check out the other blogs taking part, detailed below.
A Suitable Lie is published by Orenda Books and is available to buy now.
Reblogged this on Anita Dawes & Jaye Marie.
I can’t help feeling that you have described this book too well, far too much information and spoilers, leaving me with little inclination to read it myself?
Thanks for reading and commenting – I appreciate all feedback. Naturally it saddens me that you think I have included spoilers, but more especially that you are not inclined to read the book. The plot threads have many more twists than outlined above. The strength of the story for me was in how the author got across why the protagonist put up with the abuse, and his thought processes throughout. It is a complex subject, tackled with aplomb, but also a cracking read.
I didn’t mean to imply that the book sounded less than brilliant, for I am sure it isn’t. I simply felt that I had already read it after reading your review.
Mind you, A Suitable Lie is now in my head so I will have to read it. So your post did work!