Robyn Reviews: Where Dreams Descend

Where Dreams Descend is a beautifully atmospheric book with gorgeous, lyrical prose and a protagonist you’re always rooting for. Its marketed as loosely inspired by The Phantom of the Opera, and not being familiar with that I can’t say how similar it is, but it’s a very strong tale that stands up on its own. Circus books have almost become a subgenre in their own right since the publication of The Night Circus, and while this isn’t the strongest circus-inspired novel I’ve ever read, it’s highly enjoyable and I’m looking forward to the sequel.

The book follows Kallia, a female magician in a world where male magicians have all the power. Kallia is a showgirl, the star of Hellfire House – a casino run by the enigmatic and mysterious Jack, a male magician who returned several years ago to take over his father’s business. Kallia and Jack made a pact – she would stay and work for him as long as he taught her magic. However, when Kallia discovers a competition being held in the nearby town of Glorian – a competition to find the best magician to headline the Conquering Circus – Kallia decides its time to leave Hellfire House behind and make her own way in the world. But Jack isn’t keen to let his star go, and Glorian is full of secrets – secrets which are increasingly dangerous, especially to a woman dabbling in a man’s world.

Kallia is undoubtedly the star of the book. She’s a fantastic character – spunky, daring, unfazed by limits and determined to be the best at all cost. She radiates confidence to the point of cockiness, but inside she’s lonely and completely out of her depth. Her upbringing was incredibly sheltered and she knows little of the world, so she envelopes herself in layers of sparkle and surety until she isn’t sure how much of the true Kallia is left. I adored her interactions with the other magicians, particularly Daron Demarco, and the stars of the Conquering Circus.

Jack and Demarco, the other major characters, are more mysterious. Demarco was once the Daring Demarco, a famous magician – but after a trick went wrong and ended in tragedy, he disappeared from the circuit. His quest for answers brings him to the competition where he bribes his way in to be a judge – but he’s forgotten what it’s like to be amongst other magicians, and all his secrets are in danger of being revealed to the world. I like Demarco – he seems to have a good heart, and he’s one of very few people to respect Kallia for who she was, rather than judge her on the basis of gender – but as more about him is revealed, it becomes clear that he might not be the hero he’s painted as after all. Jack, on the other hand, is always painted as far more of a villain – the man who trapped Kallia at the Hellfire House and refuses to let her go – but is he truly evil or just trying to protect a girl he cares about? There are very few answers about Jack in this book – hopefully there’ll be more of a focus on him in the sequel.

I was disappointed that Kallia’s assistant, Aaros, was never more of a focus. A thief essentially adopted by Kallia, his character had a huge amount of potential, little of which was ever used. He had some cracking scenes and lines, but I hope he becomes more than a prop in subsequent books.

The main issue with this book is the air of mystery. The writing expertly creates a sense of foreboding, and many questions are raised – about Jack, Demarco, Glorian, the mayor, the competition – but there are few answers. I understand that this is the first book in a planned duology, so answers will hopefully come, but there’s a sense of lack of completeness which grates. I like books to stand alone even when part of a series, and this doesn’t quite manage to make itself fully its own story.

Overall, this is a recommended read for fans of gorgeous prose and books about the circus – with the caveat that it doesn’t have all the answers and the next book won’t be out for at least another year.


Published by Wednesday Books
Hardback: 1st September 2020


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.